Reviewing internship applications is one of the most important stages in building a strong internship program. A structured review process helps you evaluate applicants consistently and fairly, ensuring you find interns who align with your company’s goals, culture, and project needs. This step-by-step guide outlines how to identify top internship candidates, even when they lack professional experience, by focusing on potential, soft skills, and enthusiasm.
First impressions matter—especially when reviewing a high volume of applications. Pay attention to how well the applicant presents their materials. A well-formatted resume, personalized cover letter, and attention to detail can signal professionalism and readiness for the workplace.
Intern resumes may be brief, but they can still offer valuable insights. Look beyond traditional experience and focus on academic projects, extracurricular activities, certifications, or transferable skills. A concise, well-structured resume often reflects strong communication and an understanding of the role.
Strong candidates bring more than qualifications—they bring perspective. Look for indications of leadership, volunteer work, personal interests, or unique experiences that add diversity and innovation to your team. Even without formal experience, these traits can signal a candidate’s potential to thrive.
Look for signs of genuine enthusiasm. Customized cover letters, thoughtful personal statements, and specific references to your organization show the candidate is proactive and truly interested. These qualities often align with high-performing interns who go above and beyond.
Did the candidate follow your application instructions? Have they submitted all requested documents? Attention to detail during the application stage reflects how carefully they might complete assigned tasks. It’s a quick yet powerful indicator of dependability.
When reviewing candidates, highlight those who describe projects or coursework that required problem-solving, teamwork, or creativity. Academic achievements, even in non-professional contexts, can showcase drive, adaptability, and initiative—traits that help interns make a meaningful impact.
A scoring rubric or assessment grid can help you objectively compare candidates. Score applicants on qualities like communication, initiative, alignment with company culture, and relevant skills. This method supports consistency, reduces bias, and improves decision-making.
Source: Slideteam
A candidate’s LinkedIn profile can validate resume details, highlight industry interests, and show evidence of networking or self-learning. Check for relevant posts, shared content, or endorsements—these signals demonstrate curiosity and commitment to professional development.
Avoid rushing through applications. Thoughtful review ensures you don’t overlook qualified candidates or misjudge applicants based on incomplete analysis. Set aside focused time for application review to give each candidate a fair chance.
Application reviews take time, but finding the right intern can transform your team. With Virtual Internships, you don’t need to go it alone.
We simplify the process by:
Whether you're a startup or scaling business, Virtual Internships makes it easy to find interns who bring energy, insight, and creativity to your team.
Let us match you with your next intern today.
Learn how to effectively prepare for internship interviews as an employer, from crafting questions to evaluating candidates and showcasing company...
Selecting a remote internship provider can be an overwhelming process. Learn our tips for researching & considering the best remote internship...
Discover how collaborative internships can benefit your organization. Enhance your internship programs with these insights.